[kvdk]

my clan went GW this week, and our main problem was that, we have 1 with highest BP of all, so all other members wanted to join that persons team

but there are only 4 spots and that resulting in problems..

so my suggestion is to remove the requirement for clanmembers to be in a team, but keep the one where they have to be in the same map..
but, not everywhere, only in cirtan maps..
and next to that, to disable clanBP in cirtain other maps:

- make 'global' sharing active in guild area and public PVP maps [PKA, rb2 map]
- make 'team' sharing active in all normal maps
- disable BP sharing in ALL pvp tournament maps [exept for the couple PKT map]
- disable BP sharing in the Arena [yes, it works there, i have tested it]

this change would make the effects of clanBP easier to manage, both for people in the clan and the people they are fighting

[YellowKangaroo]

Originally Posted by kvdk

my clan went GW this week, and our main problem was that, we have 1 with highest BP of all, so all other members wanted to join that persons team

but there are only 4 spots and that resulting in problems..

so my suggestion is to remove the requirement for clanmembers to be in a team, but keep the one where they have to be in the same map..
but, not everywhere, only in cirtan maps..
and next to that, to disable clanBP in cirtain other maps:

- make 'global' sharing active in clanwar, guildwar and public PVP maps [PKA, rb2 map]
- make 'team' sharing active in all normal maps
- disable BP sharing in ALL pvp tournament maps

this change would make the effects of clanBP easier to manage, both for people in the clan and the people they are fighting

I Dont Think Its A Good Idea 0.o because
if your at guild war it will have a disadvantage over the other people. The Highest BP in my Server is 320 or something and its still growing. BP makes in harder to kill someone if its higher then yours. Thats why i say no =\

The Disable in pvp tournament maps i agree

[kvdk]

Originally Posted by YellowKangaroo

I Dont Think Its A Good Idea 0.o because
if your at guild war it will have a disadvantage over the other people. The Highest BP in my Server is 320 or something and its still growing. BP makes in harder to kill someone if its higher then yours. Thats why i say no =\

The Disable in pvp tournament maps i agree

the total diference in BP when the second-best in a clan makes a team aswell is not very big

but removing the need for teams completely will improve the speed of acting during GW

[theRationalOne]

No, because potency bites in the first place.

[elisa]

The reason i would like it to be "global" sharing in guildwar map and others same kind...is cos we are getting dc oh-so-often. And then we need to find the same ppl again to create a team in busy gw area...
Plus it annoys me there is just 4 spots in team...
And outside of gw area and pka we can use "team" sharing.

But i wouldn't like if they disable BP sharing in ALL pvp tournament maps- so no to this part. Altho... personally i dun care about that part very much... not going to those...

[kvdk]

Originally Posted by elisa

The reason i would like it to be "global" sharing in guildwar map and others same kind...is cos we are getting dc oh-so-often. And then we need to find the same ppl again to create a team in busy gw area...
Plus it annoys me there is just 4 spots in team...
And outside of gw area and pka we can use "team" sharing.

But i wouldn't like if they disable BP sharing in ALL pvp tournament maps- so no to this part. Altho... personally i dun care about that part very much... not going to those...

the pvp tournaments can only have 1 winner
so even clan members should fight eachother, but without any of them having the bonus of clanBP

or when it ends up with 2 people..
one should not get BP from a dead clanmembers ghost [it works, we tried it]

[Power_of_God]

On a whole I agree but I believe that some ideas should be changed such as the ghost glitch. I do still believe though that there should be the clan BP still able to be gotten in the PK tournaments as it is not like it is a unique feature to a select few but is a feature that everyone has access to but some utalise.

[kvdk]

Originally Posted by Power_of_God

On a whole I agree but I believe that some ideas should be changed such as the ghost glitch. I do still believe though that there should be the clan BP still able to be gotten in the PK tournaments as it is not like it is a unique feature to a select few but is a feature that everyone has access to but some utalise.

its not a glitch..
although someone may die, the rule is 'from clanmembers in the same map&team'
not 'from ALIVE clanmembers in the same map&team'

and changing that will result in problems one way or another..

instead they should simply disable it in the PKT's

[kvdk]

*bump*

[Orcstone]

personally...id simply make it so as long as your in the same map u share BP, not too hard to implement considering they got mentor BP everywhere. and as for pvp tornaments, i think its fine to share bp, means u can then work as a team with ure clan members to win....aid ure friend in ure clan to win etc....makes it more a teamplayer kind of game. atm im the strongest in our clan with like 290pot...every little helps considering the battle power system.

[Lotak]

11 members getting a HUGE benefit from one 351 potency? Make the powerful even more powerful and the even more powerful, super powerful.

No way.

The dominating guild on my server have barely any trouble winning guild war. Your suggestion will make it even easier for them to win.

[UCANTSEEMEE]

voted yes becuz i dont want kvdk to yell at me =(

[Orcstone]

u dnt like much do u lotak....question is...how long u been playing?

[Farau]

No. You fail.

[kvdk]

Originally Posted by Lotak

11 members getting a HUGE benefit from one 351 potency? Make the powerful even more powerful and the even more powerful, super powerful.

No way.

The dominating guild on my server have barely any trouble winning guild war. Your suggestion will make it even easier for them to win.

the best&second-best both controlling a team v/s simply sharing:
diference = no time wasted getting 'the BP sorted'

but the BP diferences are minimal....

currently people on my server [and believe me, we're a busy GW server these days] are spending half an hour of the flamelit, getting the teams back together due to the HUGE amount of DC's TQ still has in this damned game...